So I've been umming and ahhing about recommending this book for a number of reasons. Firstly, it is quite a large tome and so not so easy to lug around with you on public transport. Secondly, I LOVED Barbara Kingsolver's previous books The Poisonwood Bible and Prodigal Summer. A lot. Read them both twice. And for a while I wasn't sure whether I LOVED this book.
But.
It's stayed with me you see. Residual wafts of characters and colours and thoughts keep coming back. I think I do love this book but not the way you might have loved Molly Ringwald. More the way that you realised you actually loved Ally Sheedy.
Kingsolver is such a master of narrative style that all her books are interesting to read simply to see what devices she has chosen. In The Lacuna the story is told through letters and diary entries (nothing new there) but also newspaper stories and reviews.
The latter two I found a fascinating method of storytelling because an issue I am very interested in which is whether there can be more 'truth' in 'fiction'. By this I mean whether the constraints of newspaper requirements (sell papers, make it snappy and sensational) can mean the real emotion and honest motivations behind an event is lost.
For example, in 1936,
NTYC, to me, provides the emotion behind Starkie's actions and I think, more accurately portrays to me the frustrations and challenges that these men experienced. Certainly, I engage much more with Hyde's story than carefully (positively) worded newspaper articles of the time. The truth of how people 'felt' at this time was better conveyed by a made-up story.
I think I would have liked the opportunity to have had a glass of red and a talk to Hyde about truth. She once said:
"Shakespeare kept saying, ‘to thine own self be true’ … I began to wonder, which self? True to which self … I was always in bad trouble with the truth. Not so much knowing what it is, as knowing which it is. My truths had second selves, split personalities, double faces… .”
Anyhoo. Back to The Lacuna. The story is told by Harrison Shepherd, a writer cum cook for Mexican surrealists Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera. His diaries and notebooks document the relationship between the painters and exiled Russian Marxist Leon Trotsky and his wife, Natalya. After Trotsky's assassination Shepherd returns to his native
Okay. Crikey. That's a long post. And I'm currently reading Wolf Hall, another big book that will also deserve a rave. Interesting that three books mentioned in this post have fascinating male narrators written by women….
Recent Comments